Overview
- The court declared a relative nullity and ordered a renewal of the trial, citing an incomplete and redacted deposit of the investigatory file that impaired the defense.
- The Promoter of Justice must file all investigatory acts in full by April 30, 2026, with parties given until June 15 to review materials and prepare defenses.
- A hearing on June 22, 2026 will convene the parties to set the new trial calendar before the appeals court.
- Judges noted an unprecedented situation for Vatican jurisprudence involving partial filings and omissions, with disputes also touching on the timing and publication of papal Rescripta.
- The order requires disclosure of previously withheld materials, including full chat logs referenced by the defense, and places first‑instance findings from December 2023 under fresh examination.