Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Swiss Senator’s “Voluntary Ghetto” Remark Over Zurich Eruv Draws Condemnation

City authorities approved the boundary in line with Swiss law, according to community leaders.

Overview

  • The Zurich Jewish community completed an eruv after consultation with municipal officials, who signed off on the project as compliant with local regulations.
  • Community leaders describe the eruv as a symbolic halakhic mechanism using unobtrusive wires or existing structures that does not restrict public access.
  • Rabbis say the arrangement enables Sabbath carrying for those who need it most, including elderly residents, people with disabilities, and families with young children.
  • Council of States member Mauro Poggia criticized the initiative as a “voluntary ghetto” and tied his objections to unrelated issues involving Israel, the Crans-Montana avalanche, the October 7 massacre, and the war in Gaza.
  • Jewish organizations and rabbis, including Noam Hertig, Michael Ben-Edmon, and Pinchas Goldschmidt, condemned the characterization as offensive and historically inaccurate, as national debate grows and other Swiss cities explore similar eruvim.