Overview
- The Niskanen Center released the report Thursday and found no measurable reduction in violent crime after the August 2025 Guard deployment but estimated a roughly 24 percent drop in opportunistic property theft in tourist areas.
- Researchers said the Guard was largely posted in visible tourist and transit corridors where a uniformed presence deters theft but cannot easily interrupt interpersonal violence rooted in neighborhood disputes.
- The study called the operation expensive, estimating at least $185 million in costs and noting per-soldier daily expenses near $607 compared with about $384 per MPD officer per day.
- Local policing shifts appear to explain much of the broader crime decline: MPD concentrated hotspot, proactive patrols and raised its arrest rate by about 40 percent during the same period, and national crime trends also moved downward.
- Officials are pressing ahead despite the findings, with the Pentagon planning to retain troops through January 2029 and the U.S. Marshals Service seeking 1,500 more Guardsmen for a planned summer surge, while the White House defended the deployment.