Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Stefanik’s ‘Poisoned Ivies’ Tops Amazon as Reviews Divide Over Campus Speech

Early reviews warn her approach could chill protected speech.

Overview

  • Poisoned Ivies, released this week, entered Amazon’s top 10 overall and No. 1 in a politics category on day one, and Stefanik launched a national tour.
  • Stefanik frames the book as a response to campus antisemitism and what she calls anti-Americanism, drawing on accounts her office says poured in after the Oct. 7, 2023 attacks and campus protests.
  • The narrative centers on her Dec. 5, 2023 House hearing question to Harvard, Penn, and MIT leaders about calls for genocide, after which the Penn and Harvard presidents resigned.
  • A Slate review reported by Alternet says the book leaves out Gaza context and leans on disputed episodes, citing a dismissed Penn lawsuit, a Columbia inquiry dropped after a professor left, and a contested Yale protest video.
  • A Reason review says she blurs the line between unlawful acts and protected speech, backs federal funding freezes and social‑media checks for international students, and urges bans on slogans courts treat as protected.