Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Resurfaced Video of New Immigration Judge’s Misogynistic Remarks Triggers Scrutiny

The uproar renews questions over Justice Department vetting, training practices, judge readiness in abuse cases.

Overview

  • Melissa Isaak, appointed this month as a temporary immigration judge by the Justice Department’s Executive Office for Immigration Review, was cleared to start hearing cases immediately and is assigned to the Atlanta Immigration Court.
  • In a 2021 interview with influencer Anthony Dream Johnson, Isaak said there are “two types of women” and described one as a “warm, wet hole,” with a 2022 speech at the Make Women Great Again event echoing the same theme.
  • Isaak’s official bio lists no immigration law experience, and critics say that gap matters because immigration judges often weigh asylum claims and accounts of gender-based violence.
  • Her past legal work includes briefly representing three January 6 defendants, withdrawing from two cases, and assisting Roy Moore in a defamation fight tied to misconduct allegations.
  • The case highlights a broader shift reported by The Washington Post, which found the Trump administration hired more than 140 immigration judges with many lacking prior immigration experience.