Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Pooled Review Finds Transgender Women’s Fitness Matches Cisgender Women’s Within 1–3 Years of Hormone Therapy

Authors say the data are too limited for one-size-fits-all policies, calling for long-term, sport-specific research.

Overview

  • The British Journal of Sports Medicine published a pooled analysis of 52 studies covering 6,485 participants aged 14–41.
  • Despite greater lean mass, transgender women showed comparable upper and lower body strength and VO₂ max to cisgender women 1–3 years after starting hormone therapy.
  • Transgender men demonstrated expected shifts after treatment, including less fat, more muscle, and higher strength.
  • Researchers flagged major evidence gaps, including short follow-up, few elite athletes and adolescents, and inconsistent adjustment for training history, diet, and prior therapy.
  • Independent experts welcomed the synthesis but urged cautious interpretation, highlighting unanswered questions about puberty suppression, adolescent transition, and possible training-related ‘muscle memory,’ and favoring sport-specific eligibility over blanket bans.