Particle.news
Download on the App Store

New York Times Drops Freelance Book Reviewer Over AI-Linked Overlap With Guardian

The case underscores growing concern that AI tools can slip unattributed text into reviews.

Overview

  • The New York Times cut ties with freelancer Alex Preston after Monday’s editors’ note confirmed he used an AI tool that introduced language from a Guardian review.
  • A reader spotted the similarities, and the Times notified The Guardian and added a link to its review in the note.
  • Preston apologized, saying an AI tool inserted overlapping lines and that he had not used AI in his earlier Times reviews, which the paper said showed no issues.
  • Reporting documented near-verbatim echoes, including the phrase “lazy, Machiavellian Stefano” and closely matched closing lines describing the book’s setting.
  • The incident adds to growing scrutiny of AI in newsrooms, as recent missteps show these tools can blend others’ work or invent details that evade standard edits.