Overview
- A Westchester County jury found psychologist Kenneth Einhorn and plastic surgeon Simon H. Chin liable for deviating from medical standards, awarding Fox Varian $1.6 million for pain and suffering and $400,000 for future medical costs.
- The case was tried strictly as medical malpractice, with defense witnesses citing WPATH guidance while the panel determined key evaluation and communication steps were skipped.
- Testimony highlighted Varian’s depression, eating disorders, ADHD, autism, and body-image issues, and her mother said she consented after warnings about suicide risk; Einhorn denied coercion and the defense noted signed consent.
- Reporters identify the verdict as the first jury win by a detransitioner in the U.S., with roughly two to three dozen similar lawsuits pending that could affect insurer policies, hospital practices, and litigation strategies.
- The trial record was initially sealed, and independent journalist Benjamin Ryan’s reporting from the three-week proceeding provided rare public detail on the evidence and expert testimony.