Particle.news
Download on the App Store

New York Court Pauses Noah Doe Suit as Dormant Bitcoin Wallets Reactivate

The stay gives the court time to decide whether New York’s lost‑property law can apply to self‑custodied Bitcoin.

Overview

  • The lawsuit by a pseudonymous plaintiff called Noah Doe and two Wyoming firms asks a New York court to declare 39,069 long‑dormant Bitcoin addresses abandoned under Article 7‑B of state law.
  • The disputed addresses are reported to hold roughly 3.7–3.8 million BTC, a figure industry analysts value at about $230–$235 billion.
  • Blockchain monitoring has shown fresh activity that complicates the claim of abandonment, including one 14‑year dormant address moving 30 BTC and 31 named wallets transferring a combined 17,527 BTC in June.
  • Formal legal opposition has grown: a defendant using the name John Doe 33 moved to dismiss the case and the Digital Chamber filed an amicus brief arguing the plaintiffs’ theory would create legal uncertainty for self‑custody.
  • Proceedings are stayed until oral argument on July 14 so the court can resolve procedural and legal questions, and experts note that even a favorable ruling would not give plaintiffs the private keys needed to control any recovered coins.