Overview
- The National Association of Black Journalists presented its Salute to Excellence Thumbs Down award to Stephen A. Smith on Saturday, Aug. 15, saying he had “established a recurring public pattern of disparaging commentary directed at prominent Black women.”
- Smith has rejected the award as a “personal hit job,” posted an extended 45-minute rebuttal online, and aired his response on television including an appearance on Sean Hannity’s Fox News show.
- NABJ President Errin Haines defended the decision, cited past remarks about figures such as Vice President Kamala Harris, Rep. Jasmine Crockett, and a dispute with Joy‑Ann Reid, and said the organization remains open to a private conversation focused on listening and accountability.
- Coverage and commentary have split along lines of perspective, with some journalists and peers urging internal accountability and others criticizing NABJ’s public naming and Smith’s choice to press his case on a partisan network.
- Beyond the immediate clash, the episode highlights broader questions about evidence and process for public rebukes, how influential commentators wield platforms, and the potential effects on professional ties, audience trust, and opportunities Smith is pursuing.