Overview
- Collider reports a 28% Rotten Tomatoes audience score for Marshals, making it Taylor Sheridan’s lowest audience‑rated series and aligning with a critics’ note that it “lacks the narrative spark and intrigue that Yellowstone managed instantly.”
- OutKick highlights fan frustration reflected in a 29% audience rating, contrasting it with stronger scores typical for other titles in the Yellowstone universe.
- FandomWire lists a 44% Rotten Tomatoes figure for the show, underscoring that outlets are citing different snapshots of a score that is still in flux.
- SlashFilm reports director Greg Yaitanes said the pilot felt so “elevated” he did not realize it was written for broadcast television.
- SlashFilm also notes Marshals has already been renewed for a second season on CBS, even as online forums collect complaints about the writing and performances.