Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Jury Sworn in Trial Over XL Bully Mauling of Esther Martin

The case turns on Warren's claimed belief that the victim was fit to oversee his dog.

Overview

  • A jury at Chelmsford Crown Court has been empanelled, with the prosecution due to open its case on Monday.
  • The judge told jurors it is not disputed that Ashley Warren owned an XL Bully named Bear, which was dangerously out of control and injured Esther Martin, causing her death.
  • Jurors must decide whether Warren was in charge of a second dog, Beauty, during the fatal attack.
  • The defence will rely on a statutory provision that exempts liability if Warren reasonably believed Esther Martin was a fit and proper person to be in charge of Bear.
  • Warren accepts having a knife at Clacton railway station that day, with the jury to consider whether he had a lawful excuse; the trial is expected to last several weeks and may include distressing evidence.