Overview
- After a roughly two‑month trial, a Monmouth County jury found Caneiro guilty of four murders, two aggravated arson counts, and weapons offenses.
- Jurors deliberated about five hours on Friday before delivering the verdict in the Colts Neck case.
- Prosecutors said Caneiro disabled home surveillance, hid clothing with his niece’s blood, and used gasoline, then set his own Ocean Township house on fire to suggest he was also a target.
- Victims were Keith Caneiro, 50; his wife, Jennifer, 45; and their children, Jesse, 11, and Sophia, 8; Keith was found shot outside the burning Colts Neck home, while the others were stabbed and Jennifer was also shot.
- Caneiro faces a potential life sentence on May 12, as his defense continues to argue investigators had tunnel vision and notes post‑trial options, including motions and an appeal window identified by the court.