Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Judge Weighs Fate of Nearly Century-Old Kingsbrook Shul in Redevelopment Fight

The congregation asks the court to impose a trust granting it ownership after years of assurances the synagogue would be preserved.

Overview

  • A packed first hearing in Brooklyn Supreme Court drew community leaders and supporters backing preservation of the synagogue on the Kingsbrook Jewish Medical Center campus.
  • One Brooklyn Health argues the building must be razed for a $400 million campus overhaul with affordable housing and outpatient services, saying the structure lacks standalone utilities and cannot remain code-compliant.
  • Justice Richard Velasquez said he would decide soon whether the case proceeds or the hospital’s motion to dismiss is granted.
  • Congregation Chaim Albert cites a 2019 state RFP, pandemic-era promises, a prolonged lockout since 2020, and a 2024 notice of sale as grounds to seek a constructive and charitable trust establishing ownership.
  • Gov. Kathy Hochul announced an effort in December to prevent demolition and urged a negotiated solution, as the hospital points to financial pressures and its right to use its property.