Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Judge Says Karen Read Is Entitled to Return of Seized iPhones as State Retains Them Pending Appeal

The court ruled state custody cannot continue indefinitely, pausing the return order for an appeal.

Overview

  • Norfolk Superior Court Judge Michael Doolin allowed Read’s motion for the return of two Apple iPhones seized in January 2024 during the O’Keefe investigation.
  • The ruling permits prosecutors to keep the devices during an appeal, with Read’s attorney saying nothing changes for now and that the fight continues.
  • The phones are tied to a separate witness‑intimidation case involving blogger Aidan “Turtleboy” Kearney, who advocated for Read.
  • Doolin referenced an earlier ruling that rejected a proposed taint‑team search after finding a 19‑month delay in seeking a warrant was not reasonable.
  • The court noted the state’s lawful possession does not continue indefinitely, and the Norfolk DA’s office offered no immediate comment on the decision.