Overview
- U.S. District Judge Paul A. Engelmayer threw out the case with prejudice, though Gastineau can appeal.
- The ruling found Gastineau consented in writing to the use of his name and likeness in the documentary and related promotion.
- The authorization was deemed broad enough to cover extrinsic footage, including the 2023 exchange with Brett Favre, and granted Gastineau no veto rights.
- The judge called the scene newsworthy given the participants’ prominence and its connection to the long-debated single-season sack record.
- Gastineau had sued in March 2025 alleging deceptive editing, reputational harm and misuse of his likeness after the December 2024 film featured the viral clip.