Overview
- The preliminary injunction bars transfers to ADX Florence and keeps the 20 plaintiffs at the Terre Haute penitentiary as the lawsuit proceeds.
- U.S. District Judge Timothy J. Kelly found the redesignations were likely predecided and said the inmates had no meaningful opportunity to be heard.
- The case stems from President Joe Biden’s December 2024 commutations for 37 federal death-row prisoners, with 20 now challenging their redesignations.
- On Inauguration Day, President Trump ordered Attorney General Pam Bondi to ensure confinement conditions matched the “monstrosity” of the crimes, a directive the court said drove the ADX plan.
- Government lawyers argue the Bureau of Prisons has broad placement authority, while plaintiffs point to ADX’s extreme isolation; the Justice Department’s next steps have not been announced.