Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Israel Prepares Defamation Suit Against New York Times Over Kristof Column

Experts warn a U.S. defamation bid would run into high First Amendment barriers.

Overview

  • Israel's government, which ordered legal action Thursday, has not filed a case and has not said where it will sue.
  • The Kristof opinion piece alleged widespread sexual abuse of Palestinian detainees by soldiers, prison guards, settlers and interrogators, citing interviews with 14 Palestinians and NGO reports, including a disputed claim that a dog was used in an assault.
  • The New York Times said the accounts were corroborated when possible and extensively fact-checked, and its spokespeople called Israel's threat an effort to stifle independent reporting.
  • Israeli officials denounced the column as a blood libel and said it relied on Hamas-linked sources such as Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor, and they also accused the paper of publishing it to blunt an Israeli civil commission report on Hamas sexual crimes released the next day.
  • Legal scholars said any case in U.S. courts would likely fail under the actual-malice standard and face jurisdiction and enforcement hurdles, while pro-Israel protesters outside the Times building Thursday pressed for a retraction.