Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Israel Orders Defamation Case Prepared Against New York Times Over Kristof Column

Legal experts say a foreign lawsuit against a U.S. newspaper would likely falter under First Amendment standards.

Overview

  • Israel's government, which announced plans Thursday, said Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Gideon Sa'ar directed officials to pursue a defamation suit against the paper and columnist Nicholas Kristof.
  • Kristof's opinion piece reported accounts from Palestinians who alleged widespread sexual abuse in Israeli custody, including rape with objects and a claim of assault by a dog.
  • The New York Times defended the column as a deeply reported piece, saying 14 interviewees' accounts were corroborated when possible and that details were extensively fact-checked.
  • No lawsuit has been filed and no venue has been named, and legal analysts say any case in U.S. courts would face jurisdiction questions and the high actual‑malice bar for defamation.
  • Israeli officials denounced the article as a blood libel and criticized its reliance on activist-linked sources, while coverage split along ideological lines, with right-leaning outlets attacking the sourcing and Al Jazeera noting similar findings cited by rights groups.