Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Federal Judge Denies Navy Infielder’s Bid for Fifth Season of NCAA Eligibility

The decision keeps the NCAA’s final denial in effect following Navy’s admitted filing errors that short-circuited a timely appeal.

Overview

  • U.S. District Judge Julie R. Rubin on Wednesday rejected Brock Murtha’s request for a temporary restraining order, calling such relief extraordinary and not a tool to change the status quo.
  • Murtha’s six appearances at Notre Dame in 2021 were counted as a season under the NCAA’s four-seasons-in-five-years rule, which treats any game participation as using a year.
  • Navy’s initial competition-waiver request was denied last March, the 30-day appeal window was missed, and a Jan. 5 reconsideration citing clerical errors was refused.
  • The NCAA sent a Feb. 10 letter stating its decision was final and binding, and Murtha and his counsel declined comment after the ruling.
  • The case unfolds as eligibility fights continue elsewhere, including Mississippi quarterback Trinidad Chambliss, who won a preliminary injunction that the NCAA is now appealing to the state’s high court.