Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Father Speaks Out as Martha’s Vineyard Babysitter Awaits Trial in Toddler’s Death

Prosecutors point to home security video as the key evidence in the case.

Overview

  • Aimee Cotton, 40, is charged with manslaughter and reckless endangerment in the 2025 death of 2-year-old Frank “Frankie” Rodenbaugh, which prosecutors say involved hypothermia.
  • Police reports say Nest-camera footage shows Frankie and another child left strapped in car seats in Cotton’s SUV for about three hours without food or water.
  • Investigators say Cotton told them she was inside her Oak Bluffs home cooking, tending to personal hygiene and packing her son’s hockey bags during that period.
  • Cotton has pleaded not guilty, is free on bail, and is represented by attorney Harrison Barrow III; no trial date has been reported.
  • The Rodenbaughs filed a wrongful-death lawsuit and have launched a foundation and playground in Frankie’s name as Matt Rodenbaugh urges parents to “trust but verify” caregivers.