Particle.news
Download on the App Store

CSAC Denies Nkuta Appeal and Upholds Moraes Submission

Replay footage was inconclusive, failing to meet the clear and convincing standard needed to overturn the referee’s call.

Overview

  • Adriano Moraes secured a rear‑naked choke that was ruled a technical submission at 4:59 of round three on May 16, 2026, ending Phumi Nkuta’s fight in the final second.
  • The California State Athletic Commission voted on Monday to deny Nkuta’s appeal after in‑person testimony and multiple instant replay reviews.
  • CSAC executive director Andy Foster said officials watched the sequence repeatedly but remained unsure exactly when Nkuta lost consciousness and therefore could not meet the threshold to change the result.
  • The decision preserves Nkuta’s first professional loss and ends his 11‑fight win streak, and Nkuta has said he will seek a rematch with Moraes.
  • The ruling highlights limits of instant replay under CSAC procedure and keeps scrutiny on veteran referee Herb Dean while prompting calls for clearer replay rules and stronger referee accountability.