Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Court of Appeal Quashes Benjamin Field Murder Conviction and Orders Retrial

Judges said the jury was misdirected on whether Peter Farquhar chose to drink whisky of his own free will.

Overview

  • Field’s case, which the Court of Appeal ruled on Thursday, saw his 2019 murder conviction overturned with a retrial ordered.
  • Lord Justice Edis said the trial judge’s directions were defective because they removed from jurors the question of voluntariness in Mr Farquhar’s drinking.
  • The Crown Prosecution Service may seek a Supreme Court hearing before any retrial, and Field will remain in prison while such an appeal is pending.
  • Prosecutors at the original trial alleged Field covertly gave tranquilizers and spiked whisky so the 2015 death would look accidental, after a post‑mortem found acute alcohol toxicity.
  • The Criminal Cases Review Commission referred the case in 2025 following failed appeal bids, prompting a March 2026 hearing that led to Thursday’s ruling.