Overview
- Late in the fourth quarter, officials penalized Carl Granderson for roughing the passer after he brought down Giants rookie Jaxson Dart in what many observers called a textbook tackle.
- The 10-yard sack was wiped out and replaced by a 15-yard gain, though New York failed to capitalize and New Orleans won 26-14.
- Saints head coach Kellen Moore told reporters, "I saw a sack," reflecting frustration that a clean execution was punished.
- ESPN’s Scott Van Pelt labeled the decision "the worst I can recall," joining reporters and fans who criticized referee Alan Eck and his crew.
- Analyses described the play as an arms-only takedown without body-weight landing, and outlets noted the NFL has not issued a public explanation as questions mount about rule consistency and the impact on Granderson’s official sack total.