Overview
- In late May former NFL safety Eric Weddle told a podcast he doubted Underwood’s ability after attending Michigan spring practice and said the backup could be starting early, comments that amplified already growing skepticism.
- Underwood completed 3 of 9 passes for 22 yards in the spring game while backup Tommy Carr threw for 143 yards and rushed for 59, a contrast that drew notice from fans and media.
- Underwood replied to public criticism with a one-word Instagram story, “Stay,” signaling his intent to remain Michigan’s starter and respond on the field.
- Kyle Whittingham has publicly declared Underwood the QB1 and added an offensive coordinator and a dedicated quarterbacks coach to address footwork, pocket mechanics and decision-making.
- Evaluators offer mixed views—Jordan Palmer praised Underwood’s offseason progress and Sporting News ranked him No. 23 among QBs—so fall camp and Michigan’s Sept. 5 opener will be the key tests that determine whether Underwood solidifies his role or gives the staff reason to consider a change.