Overview
- Kelsey Fitzsimmons’ bench trial, which began Monday, featured Officer Pat Noonan testifying that she pointed a gun at him, pulled the trigger on an empty chamber, then tried to load it before he shot her.
- Proceedings continue Tuesday with Noonan’s cross-examination before Judge Jeffrey Karp after Fitzsimmons waived her right to a jury.
- The defense says Fitzsimmons was in a postpartum mental-health crisis and raised the weapon to her own head in a suicide attempt rather than at police.
- There is no body-camera footage and only home surveillance video of the moments before the shooting, so the case hinges on witness testimony and credibility.
- The confrontation began June 30, 2025, when officers served a restraining order obtained by her then-fiancé, who also sought emergency custody of their infant.