Overview
- At a Thursday workshop, staff presented worst-case reductions and emphasized that service cuts alone cannot resolve the deficit because of high fixed costs.
- Phase 1 in January 2027 would close the 10 lowest-ridership stations, and Phase 2 in July 2027 could expand closures to about 15 with a 50% fare increase, with layoffs and broader service reductions under consideration.
- A Chronicle analysis found roughly one in eight rides last year ended at stations slated for Phase 2 closure, representing well over 6 million trips and including higher-profile stops such as Pittsburg/Bay Point and Antioch.
- Officials said the network would contract to a core similar to the pre-1990s map, with yellow line trains turning at Concord and most service south of Daly City ending except at San Francisco International Airport.
- New fare gates are generating about $10 million annually and reducing vandalism and maintenance time, but board leaders, including President Melissa Hernandez, criticized station-closure scenarios as unacceptable, and a formal vote on contingency measures is expected later this month.