Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Austin Reaches $35 Million Settlement With Men Exonerated in 1991 Yogurt Shop Murders

City Council must approve the deal, which officials say would require borrowing.

Overview

  • The city disclosed Tuesday it had reached a $35 million agreement with the exonerated men, pending City Council approval that officials say could require loans or bonds.
  • Officials say the pact would resolve claims of Austin police misconduct and head off a lawsuit the men and Maurice Pierce’s family were expected to file.
  • A Travis County judge declared the four innocent in February after new evidence cleared them of the killings at an I Can’t Believe It’s Yogurt shop in 1991.
  • Investigators in 2025 tied the crime to Robert Eugene Brashers through advanced DNA testing and a NIBIN ballistics hit on a .380 casing linked to a 1998 Kentucky murder; DNA from victim Amy Ayers matched Brashers, who died in 1999.
  • The wrongful case carried severe costs for the men, including a death-row sentence, a life term later thrown out, years in jail, and Pierce’s 2010 death after a police confrontation, with families describing lasting hurdles finding work and housing.