Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Allahabad HC Declines To Quash 295A Case Against Priest Over 'Only True Religion' Remark

The ruling underscores that courts at the cognizance stage only check for a prima facie case.

Overview

  • The Allahabad High Court dismissed Rev. Vineet Vincent Pereira’s bid to quash a case for outraging religious feelings.
  • The FIR from Muhammadabad in Mau district alleges he told prayer meetings that Christianity is the only true religion.
  • Police filed a chargesheet in 2024 and a local magistrate took cognizance, so the case now moves forward.
  • The court held that such claims prima facie disparage other faiths under Section 295A, which punishes deliberate, malicious insults to religion.
  • The judge said magistrates only look for a prima facie case at this stage, a stance that leaves disputes like the investigator’s no-illegal-conversion finding to trial and could guide future speech cases.